| Year | Male Recipient (Sport) | Female Recipient (Sport) |
| 86-87 | Gregg Cornell (Cross Country/Track & Field) | Joanne Runge (Basketball) |
| 87-88 | Michael Gallagher (Football) | Michelle Thompson (Track & Field) |
| 88-89 | Paul Duffy (Baseball) | Cathie Karl (Volleyball/Softball) |
| 89-90 | Michael O'Donnell (Baseball) | Cathie Karl (Volleyball/Softball) |
| 90-91 | Robert Charters (Football) | Michelle McMackin (Swimming & Diving) |
| 91-92 | John Hickey (Basketball) | Tammy Silveira (Softball) |
| 92-93 | Joseph O'Connor (Basketball) | Kathleen Conley (Soccer) |
| 93-94 | Sean Lucas (Swimming & Diving) | Susan Burtoft (Basketball) |
| 94-95 | Dung Nguyen (Football) | Jeanette Goodwin (Softball) |
| 95-96 | Paul Harrington (Swimming & Diving) | Tracey Ullathorne (Softball/Soccer) |
| 96-97 | Bruce Higgins (Basketball) | Dorothy Herk (Volleyball) |
| 97-98 | David Cangiano (Swimming & Diving) | Jennifer Annaldo (Field Hockey) |
| 98-99 | Michael Marini (Baseball) | Tammy Webber (Softball) |
| 99-00 | Seto Berry (Football) | Angela Vecchione (Softball) |
| 00-01 | Christopher Carr (Football) | Amanda Sanson (Softball) |
| 01-02 | Craig Buckley (Wresting) | Jennifer Cedrone (Volleyball) |
| 02-03 | Andy Fucillo (Swimming & Diving/Track & Field) | Amanda Sanson (Softball) |
| 03-04 | Craig Buckley (Wrestling) | Kimberly Rhodes (Soccer) |
| 04-05 | Brendan Kavey (Football) | Lindsay Devereaux (Swimming & Diving) |
| 05-06 | Brendan Kavey (Football) | Lindsay Devereaux (Swimming & Diving) |
| 06-07 | Michael Sirignano (Football) | Kelsey Collasius (Volleyball) |
| 07-08 | James Quinlan (Wrestling) | Colleen Feeney (Basketball) |
| Nicole Mauro (Cross Country/Track & Field) | ||
| 08-09 | Roland Millien (Basketball) | Shannon Manning (Lacrosse) |
| 09-10 | John Marsh (Wrestling) | Allie LeBlanc (Softball) |
| 10-11 | Zachary Bates (Wrestling) | Shannon Manning (Lacrosse) |
| 11-12 | Corey Batista (Baseball) | Shelly DePina (Basketball) |
| 12-13 | Michael McPherson (Track & Field) | Shelby Farland (Field Hockey/Lacrosse) |
| 13-14 | Ricky Caruso (Wrestling) | Jenna Williamson (Tennis/Basketball) |
| 14-15 | Conor Murtagh (Soccer/Track & Field) | Taylor Clancy (Lacrosse) |
| 15-16 | Conor Murtagh (Soccer/Track & Field) | Lauren Geary (Lacrosse) |
| 16-17 | Conor Murtagh (Track & Field) | Samantha Richner (Track & Field) |
| 17-18 | Richard Smith (Swimming & Diving) | Jayci Andrews (Track & Field) |
| 18-19 | Jack Lavanchy (Football) | Jayci Andrews (Track & Field) |
| 19-20 | Edwin Morales (Wrestling) | Jayci Andrews (Track & Field) |
| 20-21 | No Award (COVID-19) | No Award (COVID-19) |
| 21-22 | Edwin Morales (Wrestling) | Kelley Reichert (Softball) |
| 22-23 | Corey Stalters (Track & Field) | Jayci Andrews (Track & Field) |
| 23-24 | Matt Josselyn (Baseball) | Serenity Sands (Track & Field) |
| 24-25 | Corey Stalters (Track & Field) | Sydney Dewhurst (Soccer) |
| Kylie Grassi (Basketball) | ||
| 25-26 | Scott Emerson (Baseball) | Kiara Abrantes (Track & Field) |